ESG | Diversifying Hiring for Professionals

Dr Caroline Burt


Subscribe Contact us

Authors


Significant Issues in DE&I

A British Exploring Society expedition in Iceland

However, at the same time, there continue to be many significant issues. As mentioned in our first article, DE&I officers regularly report feeling peripheral to their organisation and speak of a failure to embed DE&I, and there is little faith among executives that their company gets recruitment of the most talented people right. Just as concerning is the fact that a recent survey found that two in five UK businesses do not collect data on the demographic composition of their workforce [3]. In another survey, only just over a half of respondents rated their recruitment and selection processes as ‘effective’ or ‘very effective’ in positively affecting diversity and inclusivity in their company’ [4]. Moreover, there is limited reporting on other things like age and disability/SPLD, and workplace returners/career changers. Even in relation to the commonly reported characteristics, data is rarely especially granular, or cross-segmented (e.g. class and gender), which is a further weakness: more female managers and CEOs is progress, but if they come predominantly from one socio-economic background or are mainly white and heterosexual, other cross-cutting aspects of diversity remain unaddressed. 


So, undeniably one of the most important questions facing executives is how organisations can successfully turn the best intentions into reality in diversity recruitment and ensure performance enhancement. Below, we argue that now is the time to rethink hiring processes more systematically in response to the availability of much more data and increasingly sophisticated digital tools and AI, as well as to the rapidly changing economy and societal values of the 21st century, and new ways of working accelerated by the pandemic.


We set these out in two categories: 


  1. Advertising and Publicity 

  2. Application Process 

Advertising & Publicity

The process of hiring begins at the point an organisation decides it has a need for a role, followed by how it defines it, and how it goes about advertising it. These are major elements in securing a variety of applicant backgrounds. It has long been known that the bases on which women and men apply for roles differ, with women tending to apply only if they fulfil all or almost all of the requirements. At the same time, the words used in an advertisement can be gendered, racialised, age-biased or seem to exclude people with disabilities; even if this is inadvertent, it can be very damaging. If you don’t get the field, you can’t make your best appointment. 


Some obvious points to consider in the light of this: 


Be clear, concise and open 


  • Consider the picture you are presenting of your organisation; this is a sales pitch for the organisation too 


  • Explain what you can offer, and ensure to list inclusive benefits 


  • Stating salary has become a matter of debate. You may want to avoid a talent price war with competitors, but not disclosing salary (range) is likely to deter some candidates 


  • Focus only on necessary skills or experience; place weight (more) heavily on transferable skills 


  • Don’t define requirements too narrowly 


  • Signal explicitly that you are keen to receive applications from people who have the skills you are looking for, whatever their experience 


  • Avoid unnecessary detail 


  • Ensure the message is inclusive for under-represented groups: e.g. look at the language you are using and get advice 


  • Be explicit about your diversity and inclusion policies. 

 

Explore new avenues of advertising 


  • Consult with organisations representing under-represented groups and seek their advice about how to appeal to a wider range of applicants. 


  • If you are recruiting a substantial intake to the same roles each year (e.g. graduate entry jobs), analyse your marketing and recruitment strategies, including types and location of recruitment event, participation 


  • Use data analytics to examine how the careers pages of your website could work better, and which social media your applicants are using 


  • Don’t assume everyone, or even most applicants, will pick up on your vacancy by visiting your website 


  • Consider whether specialist programmes for targeted groups could be a good source of applications [5]


Look at both internal promotions and the full range of possible external hires 


  • It is important not to overlook possible internal hires 


  • Equally, competition for a role is positive, and not advertising, or relying on referrals, risks perpetuating current hiring patterns and, in worst case scenarios, nepotism. 


Consider how easy you are making it for candidates to apply for the role 


  • Many times, to the quiet fury of candidates, they are required to upload their resume and then answer the same questions long-hand all over again, for example. 


  • If you are going to buy in IT solutions in this area, take time to look for and eradicate duplications 


  • Are you able to offer flexible working? The options you are able to offer will affect your field just as language does. 


Aim to send decisions to all your candidates, with a brief explanation of the general areas in which successful applicants were strong 


  • Candidates cannot improve themselves if they have no sense of what they might improve on 


  • And your brand will benefit from being one that takes the trouble at least to send someone a rejection rather than to leave them to make a judgement about how long after an application no news turns into bad news. 

Your Application Process

Despite so many changes to the way we work, applying for a professional job has largely retained its traditional format. Submission of a resume and covering letter, sometimes a separate application form instead/as well is followed by some form of initial screening, often automated, and often focused on particular words and experiences. Sometimes there is a test too. Then, if people get over these hurdles, interviews are used to make final selections. The interview often remains the most important element, and many organisations give candidates multiple interviews over several days. 


It has long been recognised that the problem with any selection process is the vulnerability of each of its elements to coaching (often at high financial cost), socio-economic advantage, etc. 


To try and mitigate some of the effects of socio-economic and other advantage/bias, growing numbers of organisations are using platforms to provide them about contextual information about the candidates in front of them. This has been a welcome development, but while it is often helpful to outsource collating and analysing this information, it does necessitate some loss of control over data and how it is used. 


Where applicant tests are concerned, many companies have also worked to find formats that are less susceptible to coaching. Unfortunately, however, this is virtually impossible to do. There are long-established problems with ‘intelligence’ or ‘IQ’ testing: 


  • It is something that can be coached 


  • And, despite efforts by test designers, the tests can be subject to cultural bias. Perhaps the most important point for diversity recruitment is the extent to which IQ tests can keep under-represented groups out of education and employment [6]. This is because, while they are often designed with the best intentions at heart, they tend to serve instead to perpetuate trends that already exist. 


Where companies have decided to adopt a different style of test, or perhaps even a bespoke test, keeping a test secret does not level the playing field, as, except in the very first iteration, there are always people who have sat it, can re-create it or its format, and can go on to sell coaching online to those who can afford it. 


As with IQ tests, companies may therefore find significant disparities when performance is segmented to identify under-represented groups: many may not have begun to analyse this because very little data that would identify such groups is usually collected about candidates at point of application. 


Once a candidate gets to interview, it is their chance to answer relevant questions in person and for the interviewer/s to get a sense of them as a potential colleague (as well as for the interviewee to appraise the organisation and their would-be colleagues themselves). In a recent survey, 65% of employers regarded interviews as the most effective means of identifying the right person for a job [7]. 


Evidentially, this faith in interviews as a selection tool is not easy to substantiate though. In fact, despite how interviews feel to interviewers as a selection tool (there was a real person in front of me saying real things), there are many long-documented issues [8].


It would be naïve to imagine that unfairness can ever be entirely removed from any selection process, but you can attenuate its effects. The major overall message is to use all the information available to you, from the application form to the interview, holistically. Do not view each of these as hurdles on the way to interview and then place all the weight of the final decision on interview outcome. 


Some obvious ways to improve processes: 

Stage in Process Questions to Ask Actions
Application What qualifications do candidates need to do this job, and can ability be demonstrated in more than one way? Open opportunities to those with different background experience: non-graduates, for example
What do you ask applicants to do? What information do you need at this stage in the process? Decide what you really need. Take care with blind resumes – these can serve to perpetuate inequities by denying context [9]
Do your processes involve applicants providing the same information twice? Ensure that you avoid this
Could existing format be denying you access to the strongest candidates? Try paring down to essential elements only
Consider different ways of eliciting information that are clear and explicit: e.g. direct questions instead of covering letter
Contextual Information Screening What platforms are available? Make systematic comparisons
What information do they collect and provide? Is this the best information? Do some research on this; it could be crucial. Some data are more robust than others
How does their platform function? What algorithim do they use? Ensure you understand and are comfortable with the way in which the platform is processing information
Test What is the purpose of the test? Decide whether content matches purpose
How do successful applicants perform if hired? Gather data and analyse
How does test performance compare with other elements of the application? Gather data and cross-segment analysis
Ask whether this is the best form of screening? If yes, ensure you understand cross-segmentation to prevent inequities; make samples available to candidates
If no, consider alternatives
Interviews Are interviewers trained in unconscious bias? Introduce training if not
What questions are asked in interviews and how are they being asked? Ensure clarity about the purpose of questions
Do you have common structures for interviews? If not, introduce them
Do you understand the difference between character assessment and skills testing at interview? If yes, ask how you weight those
If no, you should research why this is important
Decisions How are these taken? Assess and systematise
Do you have processes for considering elements of applications together? Introduce and formalise. Remember: do not treat each element of the process as a distinct hurdle. Be holistic.

Key Takeaway

All selection processes are vulnerable to being navigated most effectively by those with the cultural (and sometimes financial) capital to do so. The beginnings of the answer to how organisations can cut through the forest of cultural/financial capital to access talent lie in more nuanced, carefully researched and considered recruitment processes, not quick fixes.


The positive point is that there are now many more ways of easily gathering contextual data and analysing it, and much more research into the dynamics of under-representation. This makes it possible to envisage imminent strides forward in diversity hiring in organisations that are willing to review their processes and think imaginatively about how to assess talent and harness the potential of data and AI in the process.


In the long term, it is likely to become clear that eschewing some of the conventional wisdom about what a strong candidate should look like yields better results from the perspective of coupling diversity with performance. Organisations that are ahead of the curve in recognising this will therefore open the door to greater profitability and value creation and set the standard for their peers. More widely, this will bring dividends for society and for individuals, improving the social impact of the organisation too. 

References

[1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-numbers-dont-lie-diverse-workforces-make-companies-more-money-2020-07-30 


[2] https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/people-and-organizational-performance/our-insights/delivering-through-diversity 


[3] https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/people-and-organizational-performance/our-insights/attracting-and-retaining-the-right-talent; https://www.recruiter.co.uk/news/2021/06/staffing-firms-fail-report-staff-diversity-finds-joint-rec-and-apsco-report 


[4] https://uk.news.yahoo.com/uk-jobs-recruitment-diversity-inclusion-targets-missed-153007321.html 


[5] Some interesting thoughts and ideas can be found at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ashleystahl/2020/07/21/10-steps-businesses-can-take-to-improve-diversity-and-inclusion-in-the-workforce/?sh=2ad44e25343e


[6] https://www.discovermagazine.com/mind/do-iq-tests-actually-measure-intelligence; https://ectutoring.com/problem-with-iq-tests; https://classroom.synonym.com/disadvantages-intelligence-testing-6381904.html; https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/iq-tests-are-fundamentally-flawed-and-using-them-alone-to-measure-intelligence-is-a-fallacy-study-finds-8425911.html


[7] https://www.xperthr.co.uk/editors-choice/face-to-face-interviews-remain-most-popular-selection-tool/106738/


[8] http://www.nationalforum.com/Electronic%20Journal%20Volumes/Lunenburg%2C%20Fred%20C.%20The%20Interview%20as%20a%20Selection%20Device%20IJSAID%20V12%20N1%202010.pdf


[9] https://www.fastcompany.com/90369924/the-effectiveness-of-blind-recruitment


Get in Touch


We have a range of DE&I, ESG, Executive Search & Selection, and HR focussed services which can be combined in various ways to create the perfect package for your business. To speak to one of our experts, please get in touch:


Contact - Africa

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Blog Subscribe

SHARE CONTENT

Photo of all the Top21 winners at the #21toWatch awards 2026, held at the Glasshouse in Cambridge.
by Jeremy Griggs • 18 November 2026
As #21toWatch 2027 opens, we look at how 147 winners from Cambridge’s innovation ecosystem have raised over £1bn and earned awards, fellowships, and more | READ FULL ARTICLE
Abstract technology image with the words 'Research Preview' overlaid.
by Charlotte Patrick • 17 November 2026
CAMBRIDGE AIQ | How can operators scale agentic AI towards autonomous networks? Our report sets out a five-stage roadmap, the key risks, and a framework for Stage 4 | READ PREVIEW & PURCHASE REPORT
16 November 2026
10 November 2026 – London – IThe search is on for the next generation of game-changing founders, pioneering companies and breakthrough innovations as #21toWatch opens the nominations window for its prestigious 2027 awards. Run by Cambridge Management Consulting, #21toWatch has a proven track record of spotlighting emerging talent and technologies from Cambridge and across the East of England - ventures with the potential to translate ambitious ideas into meaningful commercial and societal impact. Submissions typically span all areas of cutting-edge emerging innovation including artificial intelligence, deep tech, medtech, life sciences, biotechnology and climate technology. Some of the exciting entries already received for 2027 are as follows: In the ‘People’ category, biochemist, Dr Irina Gostimskaya, co-founder and CEO of Cambridge Molecular Computers, is a leading authority on reading, writing, and editing DNA. With her team at Cambridge Molecular Computers, she is building an alternative computing platform beyond silicon, using the programmability of DNA to solve previously intractable problems. Trading space for time, a DNA computer enables a desktop machine to outperform the world’s current fastest supercomputer, while consuming only a fraction of the energy. In the ‘Company’ category, pioneering femtech startup, Avline Health is building a pioneering intelligent clinical decision-support platform that combines individual patient risk assessment with evidence-informed treatment recommendations for genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM) after breast cancer. Combining vaginal microbiome sequencing, treatment history and longitudinal health data, Avline Health aims to provide clinicians with an objective severity score and a contraindication-aware treatment match, instead of a guess. CEO and co-founder, Dr. Josiane Chuisseu told us: “Vaginal microbiome testing does already exist - but nobody's built it for oncology before, and it’s very much needed. Up to 70% of breast cancer survivors develop genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM), a chronic and progressive condition caused by a drop in oestrogen levels - but it's chronically underdiagnosed because assessment still relies on subjective exams, and undertreated because clinicians are often too cautious to prescribe hormone therapy in cancer patients even when it's now shown to be safe. “As a result, two-thirds of women get the wrong diagnosis, and the treatments they do get are only effective less than 20% of the time." Meanwhile, in the ‘Things’ category, Metcycle is developing a scalable, energy-efficient technology to transform lithium-ion battery black mass into high-value critical materials. By addressing the industry’s key separation bottleneck, Metcycle aims to reduce reliance on energy-intensive and chemical-heavy recycling routes, enabling more economical recovery of battery metals while strengthening Europe’s domestic supply of critical raw materials. The 2027 #21toWatch campaign follows a year of incredible innovation across the region, with last year’s winning cohort continuing to make significant progress across investment, commercialisation and innovation: 2026 #21toWatch winner, Memorify has launched its Yoree memory platform following an oversubscribed £420k pre-seed investment round and a waitlist of more than 5,000 prospective users. Elsewhere, fellow winner, Loop52 has been selected for a share of a £2.7m Government-backed automotive innovation funding programme while another 2026 winner, Myonerv has won a £100k Innovate UK grant to advance clinical testing of its wearable stroke-rehabilitation technology, and 2026 winner, Cyclana Bio, which aims to find a cure for endometriosis, has secured approval for a 500-patient clinical study. Tim Passingham, founder and executive chairman of Cambridge Management Consulting, said: “Together, these achievements demonstrate the breadth of progress being made by the #21toWatch community, from attracting investment and bringing products to market to advancing clinical research and developing technologies with significant industrial potential. “#21toWatch is all about the importance of identifying promising innovators early and helping them gain the recognition and connections needed to scale. However, we are delighted that the impact of #21toWatch extends well beyond the awards.” Collectively, past winners have now raised more than £1billion, underlining the scale of the technical ambition among the ventures, and the importance of bringing such innovators to the attention of investors, customers and the wider business community. The #21toWatch shortlist – judged by a panel of independent judges - will be announced on 3 February 2027, with the final Top21, selected across three categories: People, Companies and Things, unveiled at an awards ceremony at Pembroke College, Cambridge, on 11 March 2027. Founders, companies and innovators can submit their own nominations through the #21toWatch website at https://www.21towatch.com/. Deadline for entries is 8 January 2027. Nominations are also invited from investors, universities and others across the innovation ecosystem. The judging process considers innovation, the challenge being addressed, influence, viability and memorability. Marks & Clerk returns as a premium sponsor of the 2027 #21toWatch campaign. Matthew Pinney, Office Managing Partner, Marks & Clerk Cambridge, said: “Cambridge has an extraordinary depth of entrepreneurial talent, and #21toWatch provides a valuable platform for recognising those innovators turning ambitious ideas into businesses with real commercial potential. We look forward to meeting this year’s cohort, learning more about their ambitions, and helping them protect and maximise the value of their innovations through intellectual property as they contribute to the region’s continuing success as a centre for innovation.” Further sponsors and the full judging panel will be announced shortly.
Big Ben and London cityscape at night – neon overlay
11 November 2026
Cambridge MC acquires Alpine Resourcing, a London-based public sector specialist, extending its reach across central and local government in the UK | READ PRESS RELEASE
A representation of agent boxes (prompts) linked into a workflow on a computer screen.
by Charlotte Patrick • 9 November 2026
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS | Cambridge AIQ assesses 13 vendors delivering agentic AI for service assurance, comparing four distinct strategies and the key factors operators must weigh | READ PREVIEW & PURCHASE REPORT
Audience at the recent launch event for the #21toWatch 2027 awards at the Glasshouse, Cambridge.
9 November 2026
A new monthly event series for scaleup founders, investors, and advisers at The Glasshouse, Cambridge. Starts 26 November with CMR Surgical’s Martin Frost CBE | READ FULL PRESS RELEASE
by Darren Sheppard • 5 November 2026
Procurement teams that invite structured external challenge — not resist it — build stronger, more defensible decisions. Learn how to use market testing and early supplier engagement to strengthen procurement authority, not undermine it | READ NOW
Visualisation of Earth with lines of data wrapped around it
by Eric Green • 4 November 2026
PROCUREMENT & AI | Neoscalers often buy the network last, under pressure. Eric Green explains the contract-term and cost risks, and how procurement discipline closes the gap | READ FULL ARTICLE NOW
30 October 2026
23 October 2026, Cambridge – Cambridge Management Consulting (Cambridge MC) has celebrated its annual corporate Green Day, bringing colleagues together for a day of environmental volunteering instead of a day in the office. On Friday 23 October, the international management consultancy, headquartered in Cambridge, teamed up with Cambridge City Council to improve wildlife habitat at Cherry Hinton Hall, a 12-hectare public park in south-east Cambridge. Working alongside the City Council’s Community Engagement team, the Cambridge MC team focused on the glade in the nature area at the rear of the park, cutting back grass, clearing away the cuttings, and sowing wildflower seeds. The work was designed to support the management of the green space and create better conditions for wildlife, while giving Cambridge MC colleagues a direct role in caring for their local environment. Tim Passingham, founder and executive chairman of Cambridge MC, explained: “Making a positive impact means being prepared to roll up our sleeves and contribute to the communities in which we work. Rather than treating environmental responsibility as an abstract corporate ambition, Green Day gives our colleagues the opportunity to contribute their time and effort to community green spaces – turning our commitment into something tangible by working alongside our local community, supporting the places we share and recognising that small, practical actions can make a difference when we take them together. “The initiative also reflects the importance of collaboration in environmental action. Individual volunteers, community groups, businesses, and local authorities all have an important role to play in maintaining accessible green spaces and supporting urban biodiversity.” While Cambridge was the focus of the company-wide initiative, Green Day extended beyond the city, with events taking place in the New Forest, and planned initiatives in London which were unfortunately cancelled due to adverse weather. In the New Forest, Cambridge MC colleagues worked with local environmental group ECO SWAY on preparing shared green spaces and planting pollinator-friendly bulbs to support bees and butterflies in the spring. Unfortunately, the London team’s efforts were cancelled due to Storm Austen, however they were excited to be joining local volunteers from Stoke Newington Urban Green (SNUG) to water and mulch young trees ahead of winter, helping them to establish and reach maturity. As an international consultancy, the team’s environmental efforts did not stop there. In France, one Managing Partner contributed to his local ecosystem by planting an oak tree, and in Portugal another Partner showed her support by planting several fruit trees. Elsewhere, consultants based outside of the UK or simply unable to travel to the three primary locations sowed tree bombs as a remote way of amplifying the day’s overall mission. Green Day forms part of Cambridge MC’s wider commitment to using its expertise, time, and resources to create positive impact. The purpose-beyond-profit company commits at least 10% of its profits to charitable causes that tally with its ‘Five Cs’: Children (and young people), Conservation (and sustainability), Cancer, Communications, and Cambridge (the Cambridge ecosystem). Alongside financial support, Cambridge MC also engages in purposeful pro bono work, gifting at least 1% of its time and expertise to help charities mature, digitalise, and reduce costs. And, uniquely, the company holds 1% of its equity in reserve for charitable use should an equity event occur. In September, Cambridge MC achieved Certified B Corporation status, marking a significant milestone in the company’s commitment to responsible business and recognising its approach to creating value for its team, clients, community, and the environment alongside commercial success. Tim said: “Our approach recognises that a responsible business is not defined solely by the advice it gives clients, but also by the contribution it makes to the communities and environments in which it operates. “By combining hands-on work with local partners across Cambridge and the New Forest, the Green Day initiative is bringing this principle to life – one green space at a time.”
More posts